One of the Rules of the Game
Today I discovered that Saturnalia had recently returned from an extended hiatus. (And by recently, I mean… many months ago.)
I sometimes wonder how many great comics I am still in mourning for that are now merrily updating away without my notice.
In any case, I happened to check up on this one and was well rewarded for doing so.
Saturnalia is one of those comics that may not blow me out of my shows, but is still fun to follow. It has manga style art, which can sometimes be a little chaotic to follow, but often with some exceptionally good scenes. The story is set in the future with your usual hot-headed protaganist and a whole set of quirky ‘friends’.
The plot, as of yet, has a lot of mysteries, and if some things seem to be done a little too neatly… well, that may be explained in time.
However, I discovered one thing that was done exceptionally well during the months I had missed.
Chapter Nine of the story focuses on an announcement made by the King of the planet. Up till then we’ve only heard strange rumors about the King, and implications that something horrible and shady may be going on behind the scenes.
The King himself is over three hundred years old, and despite the machines that keep him alive, his body is failing.
At this point you are expecting someone diabolical. This man controls the entire world – an ancient genius plotting who knows what. Your first view of him is the visage up above – a shadowy figure, isolated and alone.
What I was not expecting was a figure who looked nothing so much as a boy playing dress-up, in an outfit a few sizes too big.
Looking close, the facade of youth is clearly that, from a physical standpoint – King Hal the first appears far from healthy.
But he still acts like a kid. He suffers from a fear of public speaking. He dwells on the achievements he made in high school – in grade school, despite it being three hundred years later. Several of the silly names of cities, communities, and the kingdom itself make much more sense, if you imagine a man like this as the founder.
One does not expect him to cut such a jovial figure, but he manages it well – despite his extra pair of arms.
Now, is this all there is to him? Doubtful.
It could well be that he is a diabolical genius planning something sinister. But whether a villain or not, he is an interesting character.
The creator, Space Coyote, has done something very well – they have subverted expectations. They took what could have been something easily cliche – and mindless, and dull – and done something completely unexpected with it. And that makes it all the more fascinating.
Does this mean every artist should throw absurd characters into the story without reason or explanation? Well no – one of the reasons the character of King Hal works is that the very flaws in the character make him believable. And he clearly has a place in the story – he isn’t thrown in recklessly.
Having that sort of originality is vital for a storyteller. As I mentioned earlier, I enjoy Saturnalia, but it has rarely wowed me. Adding something new and exciting, though – that makes me remember it. That gets my attention.
I’m not saying to try and constantly one-up the reader. Don’t ruin the integrity of the story because you are afraid readers might see the plot twist coming, and don’t create wacky characters or events solely to try and shock and dazzle the reader. It isn’t about beating the reader in some obscure way – but it is about doing something to win them over and get them coming back.
But if you can carefully, subtely lead their thought process one way, and then successfully subvert that expectation with something fascinating and clever?
Then the game is already halfway won.
The Weekend, oh thank god, the Weekend
While others are off carousing at the San Diego Comic Con, I am planning to be quite merrily collapsing at home in exhaustion.
For now, though, some quick thoughts on developments from my weekly webcomic perusal:
I am flat out 100% digging Sinfest since its most recent return. Ishida has been in top form. His latest strip hardly touched on a new concept, but the execution is so perfect as to hit the nail on the head regardless.
Oh yeah! Spamamusement is back and in business, and he’s still got it!
I’ve talked about My Nemesis before, but today’s installment is really nice. Specifically, the use of shadow in the first two panels to make Rob look like a bad-ass instead of, well, like Rob. (Also, the cast page has been updated. Have I mentioned I really like interesting cast pages? Well… I do. So there.)
And finally, CRFH, as always, has me smiling with dreadful anticipation of what might be coming next.
WCCAs 2006 – Take 2
This year’s Webcartoonist’s Choice Awards are just now winding down (winners announced, ceremony on its way.)
Scandal and controversy has been abounding (which is to say, there have been some minor hiccups in the works this year.)
In spite of this, I’ve generally been pleased with the event and found the results perfectly acceptable (despite only about half of the comics I was rooting for taking home the gold.)
All in all, despite the delays and confusions abounding the ceremony this year, I like the fact that we have the WCCAs. It is one of those nice little corners of the webcomics world, and for an event that, like most online cartooning itself, is volunteer driven, it is a lot of fun for a lot of people.
Would I like it to be a bit more organized? Sure. Would I like to have the ceremony right off the bat, rather than simply a list of winners? Certainly.
But I don’t think the experience is ruined by it. Given that there wasn’t even a ceremony two years back, I’m happy just to have one on the way.
So maybe I’m just an optimist. But one way or the other, I see a lot of good comics getting some solid attention and recognition, and that’s a good thing any day of the week.
A Roll of the Dice
Over at Commissioned, they announced the advent of a new comics collective, Gamers Pair of Dice. As someone who recognizes that webcomic collectives are generally a good thing, and being a gamer myself, I dutifully went browsing through several of the strips.
I was… well, I did find myself grinning at some of them. But I’m sad to say that the majority of them left me underwhelmed.
I wouldn’t go so far as to call them Penny Arcade rip-offs. They are simply exploring the same field and making jokes on much the same subject matter, and that is perfectly fine.
But even if I don’t make the accusation, the comparison is inevitable. Penny Arcade mastered that genre of strips before most of them began, and as such, it is hard for them to stand out. The mere presence of the webcomics juggernaut, in some ways, stifles those trying to follow in its footsteps.
On another note entirely, one of the strips – a guest strip, even – left its mark on me. More specifically, it set Gato’s little song running through my head over and over again! I spoke yesterday about my poor memory, and I haven’t played the game for years, but I’ll be damned if simply seeing a virtual screenshot didn’t send the song rampaging through my mind on repeat!
A mysterious case of the Mondays?
Man, it appears to be one of those days where I’ve got way too much to talk about, and not nearly enough time to do so.
I laughed at Megatokyo today. Man, I miss that.
Sinfest is back, and has a new website! Once upon a time, I thought Sinfest was one of the most solidly updating comics out there. These days, it has its share of occasional absences, but always returns in the end. It has had some very good storylines over the last year, without losing its normal brand of humor. And now seeing the newest comic doesn’t requiring scrolling down the page ten times!
DnDorks has been getting back to its original cast of characters. This is cool and all, but I still find myself inexplicably confused by the previous arc, despite still thinking the story was awesome. However, things seem to indicate we’ll get some explanation for stuff. Maybe. I dunno. Eh, whatever. It’s a cool comic and captures the gaming experience well. That’s pretty much all I care about.
Man, my posts today seem faintly bitter, and I’m not sure why – I was actually really happy about all these comics today.
Let’s try some focusing here. On a completely upbeat note, Girly has been rocking out of late, and the upcoming storyline looks to have something to do with Policeguy, one of my favorite characters. So that’s awesome.
Anyway, time to get back to work! Tune in tomorrow, when I don’t talk about webcomics at all. Oooo, mysterious.
Ok, maybe not so much.
Speaking of back again…
I’ve noticed a handful of webcomics have returned from the lands beyond while I was gone.
This pleases me greatly.
These days, I find it safer to assume that a comic on hiatus will never more see the light of day. This isn’t to say I don’t check back with them time and time again – but this way, if they do resume, the return is all the sweeter.
Anyway, on to the show:
NeverNever has seen its share of troubles. It has had no less than three long breaks, each of them close to two years in length. Since its inception, it has had more time in absentia than actually updating.

But… it keeps coming back.
Given how many setbacks it has had, the fact that it returns time and time again (much like its primary villain, the Black Knight himself) is pretty damn impressive.
It’s a nice comic. I’m glad to see it back. For the most part, it isn’t anything heartbreaking or award-winning – just a classy little comic with cute characters, a fun story, and its fair share of silly jokes.
The new artist is looking like an absolutely perfect fit for the style, to be sure. So I’m all the more eager to see where it is going from here.
In any case, it’s likely this isn’t news to you – NeverNever’s return has been pretty heavily hyped, just as it has in the past. (As a matter of fact, I think one of its previous rebounds was when I first was introduced to it.)
There is another comic whose return, on the other hand, may have fallen a bit more under the radar: On the Playground.
I plan to give some more in-depth chatter on that bad boy tomorrow, but thought I should make sure to spread the word as soon as possible. This is a fantastic comic – filled with a lot of the cuteness that has made Count Your Sheep into such a star, though it tends to bring out its sharper edge more often than not. Of course, sometimes childhood wins out too.
In any case, some great comics that I’m glad to see back on the funny pages… so to speak.
Five for Friday
Notable things this week, at least in my humble opinion:
–Queen of Wands is back! It is still on reruns, but even those are pretty quality reading, especially with the daily commentary.
-All that stuff I posted about My Nemesis? Yeah, I was wrong, Kal’s still a dick. But hey! the strip is still very pretty and has its own fun brand of humor. I’m not entirely sure where he is going with it all, but its fun to read nonetheless. (Now, as to whether this latest development makes the strip more or less deep I’ve not yet decided. Of course, as long as I’m enjoying reading it, it probably doesn’t even matter.)
–Some interesting stuff going on over at Girls with Slingshots, and not just because they are at a strip club. Rawr!
-I’ll admit, it was kinda fun seeing Rayne end up in over his head. He’s one of those guys that always seems to come out on top (no pun intended), so having things not end up perfectly for him was perversely satisfying.
-Finally, I just started reading Goblins. It does the gaming parody riff rather well – but it also seems to have a good sense of more serious elements.
Aaaand, that’s all for this week.
Spreading the love of Mad Science.
So you may have heard the news – Narbonic is going to be free again.
Good news for me – I can finally get all my friend to read the comic now.
Of course, Scott Kurtz raised an interesting question – is it actually worth going to the effort of reading it, with it scheduled to end within half a year?
Fortunately the answer is easy: Well duh. Of course it’s worth it.
I read books, I watch movies, I engage in all manner of activities with a definite ending. Sure, it’s a slightly difference experience to read a work that is complete vs one that has the promise of many on-going years – but that doesn’t directly impact on the quality itself.
And rest assured, Narbonic is quality. No question about that.
Of course, Kurtz brought up another question, too: “Has the subscription model failed Shaenon Garrity?”
That’s harder to answer. I’ve given my thoughts on Modern Tales before.
Since then, we’ve been promised that big changes are coming. Changes that they’ve been in need of for a long time, and become even more pressing with the departure of Narbonic.
We haven’t seen too much of those changes yet. Graphic Smash has admittedly been adding more stuff to it’s already solid roster. Girlamatic has had a few nice additions, and some comics have returned from hiatus.
Modern Tales itself, though… I dunno, man. I dunno. I’m still waiting to see what’s to come. I mean, they’ve got Eric freaking Burns as the editor – that’s a man who cares about comics! But half a year since the announcement, and Modern Tales hasn’t shaped up yet. The change may be coming, but it is taking it’s time.
Still, anyway, this isn’t anything I haven’t said before. It is simply that things are growing a tad more pressing with this latest bit of news.
So, Kurtz asks, has the subscription model failed Shaenon Garrity?
Well, I can’t answer that question – I imagine only Shaenon can. But I have the feeling that if there was a failure at hand, it wasn’t the subscription model itself… it was this specific implementation of it.
Anyway, enough of the duldrums. Narbonic will be free.
Let me say that one more time:
Narbonic will be free.
So on July 1st, if you aren’t reading it already… well, I don’t think anymore needs to be said.
WCCAs 2006
So amidst the usual clamors of favoritism, popularity contests, redundancy and the like… I’m pretty pleased with the list of nominees for this round of Webcartoonist Choice Awards. There are familiar names in most every category, but also a lot of comics that are new to me, and I know this has been a great resource in the past to finding new and exceptional strips.
So, without further ado, here are the ones I am rooting for:
Outstanding Comic:
A hard call for me between Girl Genius and Narbonic… but since I am still in the intro stages of Girl Genius, while Narbonic is heading towards its grand finale, I think Helen (and co.) get my vote. One way or another, I’m hoping mad science wins the day!
Outstanding Newcomer:
I’m not familiar with a lot of the others, but I find it highly unlikely anything would be able to beat out Gunnerkrigg Court. This comic came out of nowhere to floor a lot of readers on the web, and I think it will have a stellar showing.
Outstanding Artist:
My initial response here was towards A Lesson is Learned but the Damage is Irreversible, but I think Sarah Ellerton (Inverloch) is where my heart lies – I remembered when I was first introduced to the comic (from last year’s awards, even), it was the art that drew me in and kept me reading. That says a lot.
Outstanding Black and White Art:
Hard choices. Very hard choices. I think I’d be happy with either Digger or Sam and Fuzzy – both aren’t just well-drawn black and white comics, but comics that specifically put it to exceptional and brilliant use.
Outstanding Character Art:
I’m thinking Ugly Hill here, though with some of the weird freaky characters from this last year in Wapsi Square, it could be a contender.
Outstanding New Character Design:
Aki Alliance works for me.
Outstanding Environment Design:
There are a few on here I’m not familiar with, but I’d be surprised if they can overcome the wonder that is Copper.
Outstanding Layout:
Man. As much as my heart would root for Copper again, I have to give credit where it is due – layout is what A Lesson is Learned but the Damage is Irreversible takes to all new levels.
Outstanding Use of Color:
These choices are getting harder. This one I’d be happy with any of the nominees winning, really.
Outstanding Use of Flash:
I’m gonna go with Hold My Life for this one, since the others are either unknown to me, I haven’t actively noticed anything special using flash, or it has actively hindered the viewing experience. It’s not just a default win, though – I actively like the little reading style Hold My Life has going for it.
Outstanding Use of Infinite Canvas:
Ah, infinite canvas. A lot of names new to me on here – I think I may do some research on these guys before coming to any conclusions.
Outstanding Web Design:
I am partial to the simple elegance of Starslip Crisis for this category. Some of the others are flashier (no pun intended), but don’t really perform quite so well.
Outstanding Writer:
Hmm. Another tough call, but I think Shaenon Garrity (Narbonic, Li’l Mell, Smithson,Trunktown) is where my loyalties lie. Every one of her strips keeps me coming back, and are all at the top of my reading list. Can’t argue with that.
Outstanding Character Writing:
Because the last category wasn’t hard enough, see. Man, I dunno. Just pick something, they’re all fantastic. I think OotS, Scary Go Round, or Something Positive would be at the top, though. That’s about as narrowed down as I can get it.
Outstanding Dramatic Comic:
Something Positive. Period. Full stop.
Outstanding Comedic Comic:
Man, I knew I should have campaigned more for Dr. McNinja. As it is, I’ll have to root for Shortpacked.
Outstanding Long Form Comic:
This is always something that is harder to tell in an younger comic, but I think Gunnerkrigg Court is the winner here. Whether it’s potential holds out is yet to be seen, but I’d be surprised if it didn’t stay true to form.
Outstanding Short Form Comic:
The Perry Bible Fellowship for the win.
Outstanding Single Panel Comic:
Saturday Morning Breakfast Cereal. For all that it is occasionally hit or miss, when it is at its best, nothing else can even compare.
Outstanding Story Concept:
Both Girl Genius and Gunnerkrigg Court are exceptional. I think Gunnerkrigg Court wins by a hair, since some of the elements behind the scenes are truly inspired.
Outstanding Anthropomorphic Comic:
Digger, in my opinion. Where the anthropomorphism is actually related to the story, and neither an obsessive focus or completely tangential. And, of course, its a wickedly awesome comic.
Outstanding Fantasy Comic:
I know I shouldn’t say Order of the Stick for this one, since it is more parody than pure fantasy… but I think I will, anyway.
Outstanding Gaming Comic:
Yeah, yeah, yeah, Penny Arcade is the obvious choice for this, the popular one, the ‘sell-out’… but that’s because it’s the best.
Outstanding Slice-of-Life Comic:
So… of the ones on the list, Devil’s Panties is the only one I feel really fits the category.
Outstanding Romantic Comic:
I know everyone’s going to vote Questionable Content, but as much as I like the indie kids, Sordid City Blues feels a lot more real about the romance.
Outstanding Science Fiction Comic:
In a surprise (even to myself), I think Zap has my vote here. It’s a clever little comic with gorgeous art, and I think it does a great job of preserving the sense of wonder that any good sci-fi comic needs.
Outstanding Superhero/Action Comic:
And finally a tough call for the last spot! Another selection of great comics, and I think I’d either go with The Green Avenger or Magellan. They are very different comics – one is very focused, the other more epic in scope.
Overall, I think the fact I had a lot of trouble picking out my favorites in each category says a lot about the selection – a slew of good comics that have gone up against each other.
We’ll see what is to come, but I suspect I’ll be happy regardless of who the winners really are.
My only regret is that the list needs more ninja.